Armies of Liberation

Jane Novak's blog about Yemen

Civil society activists condemn Yemeni scholars’ fatwa on writer as politically motivated exploitation of religion

Filed under: Civil Rights, Civil Society, Media, Religious, Yemen — by Jane Novak at 12:36 pm on Saturday, February 4, 2012

Rejecting Taqfirism flat out. And they are correct that a civil state does not reject religion but protects the rights of all religious persuasions equally.

RSF condemns the Takfeer campaign against Yemeni writers

A statement released by Revolution Salvation Front (RSF) on the apostasy campaign against the Yemeni writer, Bushra al-Maqtari

Condemnation Statement

O’ great people..O’ revolutionaries and freedom seekers in all squares of freedom and change
In deliberate abuse to the freedom of belief and approaching elimination and dominance of religion employing, the Yemeni writer Mrs. Bushra al-Maqtari, subjected to Takfeer (apostasy) campaign by known extremist groups.

Recently, these groups issued Fatwa, an Islamic edict by clerics, named as “The Olama’s Fatwa on abuse the Islam and Allah”, in which they named four writers: Bushra al-Maqtari, Fikry Kasim, Muhsin A’aid and Sami Shamsan of being “abused Islam” and described with “apostasy” and “Kufrism”.

The Fatwa elaborated by talking about an article of writer Bushra Maqtari, reported some of severed phrases from the article and interpreted it according their special orientation and political purpose for abuse and incitement to murder against the writer.

The RSF deplores and condemns this unjust Fatwa and that was not in fact Fatwa as it is just exploitation of religion for the liquidation of opponents to insert illegal ambitions, seeking to provoke sedition in society and exclusion of political opponent bigotry and bad interpretation of words away from its meanings.

It rejects the Takfeer at all. The so-called “Olama’s Fatwa on abuse the Islam and Allah” only regarded as a matter of political exploitation of religion to rein the other opinion and intellectually terrify. Such method already used by the same extremist groups against others and authorized the killing of children and women during previous political conflicts especially those infamous fatwa issued against the Yemen southerners during the civil war in 1994, misbelieved as “the war of apostasy and separation”. As well, many writers subjected to such Fatwas, as Dr. Abdul Aziz al-Maqalih and Dr. Hamood al-Awdi.

The RSF warns against going too far in using and monopoly religious and national eligibility by a group extremists and radicalists as Saleh’s regime did to weaken and exclude opposition opponents. Such behavior regarded as a crime must not be silent by the community.

It considered use of the mosques and public spaces to incite against other faiths, beliefs and ideologies as a blatant open call for incitement to murder and crime must be punished.

In this regard, the RSF calls upon the Ministry of Endowment to prevent the use of mosques to religious Takfeer, sedition and hatred in the community.

RSF also calls on political parties, human rights and civil society organizations, social and revolutionary representations, thinkers, writers and all the people to respond to such serious actions that threaten the security, stability and safety of the community.

RSF condemns the sites that published writings of abusive terms such as NabaNews and YemenPress, demanding to be prosecuted in accordance with the law.

Issued by The Peaceful Revolution Salvation Front
Date 03/02/2012

Fatwa is here and Gt’d here in article entitled: “The text of the fatwa, and the image” .. scientists Yemen opinion about insulting the divine: the article described Bushra Maqtari, and demanding closure of sites that published her article, and called for abusers to declare repentance”

Interesting to note that AQAP in Jaar banned some of the same newspapers that the scholars are also railing against.

4 Comments »

1

Comment by Nezar Naji Al-awlaki

2/8/2012 @ 8:15 am

This Fatwa could have happened to me or any liberal new-generation Yemenis unless by luck’s grace i personally had been outside Yemen for more than 16 years. You can’t criticize Mohammed, the Qura’an and you can’t criticize Allah. These things are considered absolute “good”. No discussion about this “goodness” should be initiated. Islam is a “closed” ideology that doesn’t need improvements or instead “thought not to”. It is “perfect and complete” so no one dare to locate passive portions or dare say the opposite of what the majority think of Islam is true. I am not against Islam because i don’t consider myself an atheist. Rather i am an agnostic person with Islamic mind-set who seeks knowledge. However, sincerely admitting, (we need to modernize Islam so that we can get rid of the dictatorship of 15-century rusted Sharia).

2

Comment by Jane Novak

2/8/2012 @ 10:09 am

The oldest known Koran was discovered in Sanaa and they stopped access to it when the scholars first noticed some small discrepancies with the text used today which is believed to have been the same since the time of Mohammed. I’ve always been curious what the old one says that is different. Its never been fully translated.

One of the fatwa’d writers wife divorced him after 16 years and 6 kids. It sends a chilling message to free thinkers in Yemen.

3

Comment by Nezar Naji Al-awlaki

2/8/2012 @ 12:48 pm

Even if they re-discover it, Muslims won’t accept the meaning variations. Not even the language discrepancies. (إنا انزلنا الذكر وإنا له لحافظون) This verse from the Qura’a reads as: “I, Allah- the al-mighty sent down my revelation words and it is my pledge to preserve it as the same, letter-to-letter until the hereafter day.” It is believed to be divinely protected from distortion and adulteration.

4

Comment by Jane Novak

2/8/2012 @ 4:15 pm

oh i didnt realize that it is thought to be divinely protected from distortion.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Bad Behavior has blocked 3679 access attempts in the last 7 days.